Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats - Eat Proper Good

Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats Spoon - Eat Proper Good

Peanut Butter Cup and Apple Cinnamon
Overnight Oats - Eat Proper Good

4.8 / 5 (211 reviews)

Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

Name: Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats
Brand: Proper Good
SKU: 165762
Price: 3.49 USD
Availability: OutOfStock
Rating: 4.83 (211 reviews)

with 15g Grass-Fed Whey Protein

Product:

Earn 3 Loyalty points for this purchase Log In/Sign up

Find us on your next grocery run

At Walmart, Target, H-E-B & 20+ more stores nationwide.

Find a store

Sweet and gooey chocolatey goodness packed with old fashioned oats, cocoa, peanut butter, and protein for the perfect meal! It tastes like a peanut butter cup, for a breakfast that's healthy but tastes like dessert!

15g Protein

Refreshing & Delicious

High Fiber

99% Lactose Free

Low Sodium

Gluten Free Ingredients

The most refreshing, easy & delicious breakfast - fuel your day!

Proper Good Promise — Love it or get your money back

Feel the love

27,955 Reviews

This has turned into my favorite flavor! It's just sooo good!! Makes for an amazing breakfast

Hannah L. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

I like the convenience and it's good for breakfast or lunch. It's a good meal that keeps you full long

Amber W. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

This is a great breakfast option!

Lionel B. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

I like the convenience and ease of this product. Love the flavor. Great to add mix ins.

Casie G. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

So yummy! Way to start the day!

Terry W. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

So delicious & I love all the protein!

Kelly N. · Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats

VERIFIED BUYER

250,000 Happy Customers

Perfect Meals

INGREDIENTS:

Whole Grain Oats, Brown Sugar, *Whey Protein Isolate, Peanuts, Cocoa Powder, Natural Flavor.

ALLERGEN WARNING:

Peanuts, Milk

Say goodbye to
bland Ready Meals

Say goodbye to
Low Nutrition

Say hello to
Tasty Meals

How Do We Compare?

Others

Homemade taste

Absolutely!

Sort of!

Ingredients you recognize

Only the best

Sometimes?

Unique and innovative flavors

Always cooking up more!

Meh...

Rave reviews on Shark Tank

They loved us!

They didn't respond...

25% off your first order, 15% off every order after

Subscribe and Save

Full price, every time

Free Shipping over $35

Yes!

No way!

Oats, Soup & Pasta

Better for you

Easy Meals

Shelf Stable

Homemade Taste

Oats, Soup & Pasta

Better for you

Easy Meals

Shelf Stable

Homemade Taste

Oats, Soup & Pasta

Better for you

Easy Meals

Shelf Stable

Homemade Taste

Oats, Soup & Pasta

Better for you

Easy Meals

Shelf Stable

Homemade Taste

Why Proper Good?

No Fridge Needed

Shelf-stable meals that are always ready when you are — no refrigeration needed!

Ready in 90-seconds

Hot, hearty, and ready to enjoy in just 90 seconds. Fast food, made better!

Clean Ingredients

Packed with wholesome, clean ingredients you can trust — deliciously simple.

Customer Reviews

4.8

Based on 211 reviews

5189
415
33
21
13

Dave R.🇺🇸
Yum, yum, yum!
12/05/25
Back for more! Love this anytime of the day, but especially as a healthy dessert!
Proper Good
Hello Dave! We're delighted to hear you're loving our oats as a healthy dessert! Can't wait to see you back for more yum, yum, yum!🙌🙌
Diane T.🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
I love this so much.
12/05/25
I love this so much. A great and easy way to start off the day.
Proper Good
Hello Diane! We're over the moon to hear you love our meals so much! Can't wait for you to enjoy more of our meals in the future.🙌
Jaida🇺🇸
Smooth and rich
12/01/25
I purchased the peanut butter oats and the oats were soft, flavorful, and not artificial tasting. It does taste more like chocolate then peanut butter thought but I liked it more that way.
Proper Good
Hello Jaida, we're so glad you found our Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats to be soft, flavorful, and not artificial tasting! Who knows, maybe you'll discover your new favorite flavor next time you shop with us. Happy snacking!
Anita G.🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
SO GOOD!
11/23/25
These are AMAZING! They taste like a peanut butter cup without being too sweet. It is a great addition to my breakfast line-up! I am so happy I tried these!
Proper Good
Hello Anita! We're delighted to hear you loved our Peanut Butter Overnight Cups! Stay tuned for more tasty surprises coming your way!🙌
BLAKE M.🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
Get your candy fix in a healthy breakfast or anytime
11/21/25
Like a Reese's cup on steroids!. . . so flavorful AND good for you!
Proper Good
Hello Blake! We're delighted to hear that our oats satisfies your candy cravings in a healthier way. 🙌
Kay H.🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
Very good
11/17/25
Tried the peanut butter cup oats,it had a very good flavor. Was good cold, I didn't try it warm. If available in my area, I would try it again and maybe warm this time.
Proper Good
Hey there Kay! So glad you enjoyed the oats! Next time, try them warm for a cozy twist. Looking forward to your next visit!🙌🥄
Tabitha🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
So good
11/14/25
Love love this
Proper Good
Hello Tabitha! We're ecstatic to hear that you loved our oats so much! Can't wait to see you back for more shopping fun soon. 🙌
Dave🇺🇸
Proper Good = Really Great!
11/10/25
This is my new grab and go breakfast treat. Best overnight oatmeal on the market!
Proper Good
Hi Dave! We're thrilled to hear you think our overnight oatmeal is the best on the market. Stay tuned for more tasty treats to come your way!🥜🍫🧡
Sav🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
Tasty!
11/01/25
My boyfriend loved this! Way better than eating a bunch of candy to fulfill a craving too!
Proper Good
Hi Sav! We're so glad to hear that your boyfriend loved our meals! It's a great alternative to satisfying those sweet cravings. We look forward to serving you both again soon!🙌🙌
Paul G.🇺🇸
Verified Buyer
Almost there
10/23/25
The Peanut Butter overnight oats are a great concept and gets full marks for execution. Chocolate? Yes. Peanut Butter? Of course! But taste? Therein lies the rub. Just like my great aunt, not all the way there. It needs a bit of natural sweetener to pull it all together.
Proper Good
Hello Paul, Thanks for giving the Peanut Butter Cup Overnight Oats a try! 🙌🥜