Ultimate Comfort: Hearty Chicken Mushroom Soup Recipe

Ultimate Comfort: Hearty Chicken Mushroom Soup Recipe

Estimated time to read 12 minutes

Ultimate Comfort: Hearty Chicken Mushroom Soup Recipe

Ready to create a chicken mushroom soup that’s both delightful and health-conscious? This article delivers practical steps to blend the rich flavors of chicken and mushrooms into a soup that’s as nourishing as it is satisfying, without the heavy creams. Simple methods, ingredient insights, and healthy twists await.

Key Takeaways

  • Proper Good’s Chicken Mushroom Soup is a convenient, high-protein, and health-conscious comfort food that’s gluten-free and keto-friendly.
  • Creating the perfect Chicken Mushroom Soup involves choosing the right cut of chicken, mushrooms, and herbs for flavor, as well as employing techniques like sauteing and simmering for optimal taste.
  • For a creamy soup without heavy cream, you can use gluten-free thickeners or coconut milk, which also adds nutritional benefits along with the creamy texture.

Proper Good Chicken Mushroom Soup

Proper Good Chicken Mushroom Soup


If you’re looking for a flavorful, filling, and fuss-free soup, look no further than Proper Good’s Chicken Mushroom Soup. Packed with white chicken breast, fresh cut mushrooms, and a protein-packed bone broth base, it’s a delectable choice for those who crave hearty comfort food.

But the goodness doesn’t stop at taste. This chicken and mushroom soup:

  • Comes with 11g of protein
  • Is gluten-free
  • Is keto-friendly
  • Has no added sugar

Making it a delicious and healthy option, especially for those watching their intake.

The best part? This delicious soup is shelf-stable, meaning you can have it at home, at work, or on-the-go. Customers rave about the heartiness, the flavor added by the bone broth, and the convenience of heating and eating right out of the bag.

The Essentials of Chicken Mushroom Soup

Assortment of fresh herbs and sliced mushroomsEvery great recipe starts with the basics, and our chicken mushroom soup is no different. At its core, this soup is about three things: the chicken, the mushrooms, and the seasonings. But within these three elements, there is a world of variety and potential.

Choosing Your Chicken: Breasts vs. Thighs

Chicken is the star of the show in this soup, but which cut should you use? While raw chicken breasts are a popular choice, simmering them in the seasoned broth before shredding can enhance the flavor of the soup.

On the other hand, chicken thighs, with their rich flavor and higher fat and calorie content, pack an extra punch in soups like cream of mushroom soup. Some people prefer them for their juicy texture and depth of flavor. But if you’re watching your fat intake or prefer a lighter taste, chicken breasts are a great option. They cook faster and can give the soup a delicate, lean texture.

The Mushroom Medley: Selecting the Best Varieties

There are numerous options available when selecting mushrooms. You can use:

  • white or brown mushrooms
  • crimini
  • baby portobellos
  • sliced portobellos
  • sliced mushrooms

Each type of mushroom works well in this recipe.

Different types of mushrooms can bring their unique umami taste, enhancing the overall flavor of the soup. Some mushrooms, such as oyster mushrooms, have a smooth texture that works great in soups, stews, and casseroles. How you cook them also matters. For instance, microwaving mushrooms can make them even more flavorful compared to boiling them.

Herbs and Spices for That Perfect Taste

No soup would be complete without the right herbs and spices. They bring in cool flavors, add some color, and mix things up a bit in the world of soup cuisine.

When making chicken mushroom soup, you can add the following ingredients to make it taste super delicious:

  • Thyme
  • Oregano
  • Salt
  • Pepper
  • Worcestershire sauce

The choice between fresh and dried herbs can also affect the soup’s flavor. Fresh herbs should be thrown in near the end of cooking or after the soup’s done, while dried herbs should go in earlier since they release flavors over time and usually have a stronger flavor than fresh ones.

Crafting the Creamy Base Without Heavy Cream


A creamy chicken mushroom soup being poured into a serving bowlMaking a creamy soup doesn’t always mean you need to reach for the heavy cream. There are a variety of ways to achieve that creamy texture using alternative thickeners and dairy-free options.

We will demonstrate how to create a creamy base without the use of heavy cream.

The Role of Flour: Gluten-Free Options

Using flour in chicken mushroom soup not only thickens it but also gives it a creamy texture. You can make a slurry with 2 tablespoons of flour and cold water, then add it gradually to the soup to avoid lumps. Another way is to mix 2 tablespoons of flour with ¼ cup of cold water for each cup of medium-thick sauce to the soup.

But what if you’re avoiding gluten? No worries! You can use gluten-free thickeners such as:

  • cornstarch
  • tapioca starch
  • arrowroot starch
  • potato starch

These alternatives can give your soup the desired creamy texture without using regular flour.

Dairy-Free Delight: Coconut Milk Magic

For those who follow a dairy-free diet, coconut milk is a great alternative for creating a creamy base. It makes the soup all creamy and rich without using any dairy, like heavy cream. Plus, it brings a subtle coconut flavor that adds an interesting twist to the soup.

Coconut milk is not just about the creaminess and flavor. It’s packed with medium-chain fatty acids, vitamins A, C, and E, and minerals, making it a healthy addition to your soup. It’s also lactose-free and works for plant-based diets. On top of that, it has anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, and antifungal properties that could help with cholesterol, weight loss, and antioxidants.

Simmering to Perfection: Cooking Techniques


A large soup pot simmering with chicken mushroom soupThe secret to a perfect soup lies not just in the ingredients but also in the cooking techniques. From sautéing to simmering, mastering these techniques can help you achieve the perfect consistency and flavor in your chicken mushroom soup.

Mastering Medium Heat: Saute and Simmer

Sauteing and simmering are two cooking techniques that can transform your soup from good to great. Sauteing is cooking food in a bit of fat over high heat, while simmering is when you cook food in liquid at a lower temperature than boiling. Understanding the appropriate times to saute and simmer is key in soup preparation.

The ideal temperature for sautéing chicken and mushrooms for soup is medium-high heat. This ensures everything cooks just right without getting burnt or staying undercooked. On the other hand, to simmer soup right, you need to keep the heat between 185 to 205ºF (85 to 96ºC) so it cooks without boiling over.

From Stovetop to Tabletop: Serving Suggestions

When your soup is prepared, it’s time for serving. And the way you serve your soup can make all the difference. You can totally just throw some rice into the bowl with the creamy chicken mushroom soup, or you can use it as a base and pour the soup over it for a cozy meal.

If you’re a fan of bread, you can dip some crusty bread in the soup, or even serve the soup in a yummy edible bread bowl. And to really elevate your soup, try adding some fancy toppings like parsley, crispy chicken skin, roasted vegetables, fresh herbs, or parmesan cheese for a more refined look.

Leftovers and Storage: Keeping Your Soup Fresh

Leftovers are a reality of cooking, especially when it comes to soups. But with the right storage techniques, you can keep your leftover chicken mushroom soup fresh and delicious for days, or even months.

Refrigerate Right: Tips for Cooling and Storing

Once you have savored your chicken mushroom soup, there might be some leftovers. The first step is to let the soup cool at room temperature for no more than two hours before you pop it in the fridge. This helps to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria.

When storing the soup in the fridge, use airtight containers. BPA-free plastic containers or glass ones like the Oxo Good Grips 4-Cup Glass Round Food Storage Container are excellent choices. This way, you can keep the soup in the fridge for about 3-4 days without compromising its taste or quality.

Freezing Fundamentals: Long-Term Storage Solutions

Freezing provides a viable solution for storing the soup for extended periods. To freeze your soup, scoop the cooled soup into freezer-safe containers or bags, leaving some space at the top. Glass containers are also a good option if you’re planning to store it for 2-3 months.

To thaw frozen soup, let it thaw in the fridge overnight. Then, heat it up gently in a saucepan on low heat, stirring occasionally to maintain its quality and taste. But remember, for the best taste, it’s better to eat it within four months.

Quick & Convenient: Proper Good's 90-Second Chicken Mushroom Soup


A person enjoying a bowl of chicken mushroom soupFor those short on time or not in the mood to cook, Proper Good’s 90-second Chicken Mushroom Soup serves as a swift and convenient choice. It’s a delicious option that’s ready in just 90 seconds!

With white chicken breast, fresh cut mushrooms, and a protein-packed bone broth base, it’s a delicious choice for those who crave hearty comfort food like rotisserie chicken. Not to mention, it’s gluten-free, keto-friendly, and comes with 11g of protein.

You can grab Proper Good’s 90-second Chicken Mushroom Soup from their official website or on Thrive Market. Customers are totally loving it! They’re raving about its smooth texture, easy packaging, and the top-notch broth and mushrooms.

Elevating Your Soup Game: Unique Add-Ins and Toppings

Chicken mushroom soup, also known as chicken soup with a twist, allows ample room for creative experimentation. From unique add-ins like creamy mushroom soup to unexpected toppings, there are countless ways to elevate your soup game, including the delicious mushroom soup chicken.

Spice It Up: Adding Heat to Your Bowl

For lovers of spicy food, adding some heat to your soup could be a delightful option. Adding spicy ingredients like black peppercorns, cayenne pepper, and chili flakes can take your soup to another level. They can bring out the flavors in the soup slowly, giving it a different fruity or smoky flavor depending on what you use.

Adding heat to the soup is not just about the kick. It also helps to balance out the flavors. Here are some ways to add heat and balance the flavors:

  • A bit of olive oil
  • A squeeze of lemon
  • A spoonful of sugar
  • Warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, mace, and cardamom
  • Hot spices like cayenne pepper and red pepper flakes

These additions can help make the flavor pop and create a well-balanced soup.

Citrus Twist: Lemon Juice for Brightness

Adding a bit of lemon juice can significantly enhance your chicken mushroom soup. Apart from its refreshing taste, lemon juice can really make the flavor of the soup pop. It brings out the flavors, goes great with seasonings like thyme, parsley, and turmeric, and makes the earthy flavors of the soup stand out more.

The amount of lemon juice you add to your soup is totally up to you. But generally, around 1 tablespoon should give your soup that nice citrus kick. So, the next time you make chicken mushroom soup, don’t forget to add a little zing with some lemon juice.

Grain Goodness: Rice and Noodles as Hearty Mix-Ins

If you’re looking to make your soup a bit more filling, consider adding some grains. Wild rice or wide homestyle egg noodles can add a hearty touch to your chicken mushroom soup. You can either add the cooked rice or noodles directly into the soup or serve them on the side.

Cooking rice and noodles properly is key to perfect soup. You should cook the rice separately, either in a saucepan with soup liquid and water or just water, and then add it to the soup. For noodles, boil and drain them separately before adding to the soup, or you can cook them directly in the soup if you prefer.

Pairing with Proteins: Incorporating Different Meats

The versatility of chicken mushroom soup allows for experimentation, such as the incorporation of various meats. Adding a variety of meats can not only add a different dimension of flavor but also increase the protein content of your soup.

You can try adding beef to your soup by sautéing it with mushrooms and adding some dried herbs, salt, and pepper. Or you can simply swap the chicken with lean beef in the recipe. If you’re a seafood lover, try adding some shrimp, scallops, and fish along with the chicken and mushrooms. No matter what additional meat you use, the possibilities are endless.

Enhancing Flavor Naturally: The Power of Broth and Wine

Utilizing a quality broth and a hint of wine can elevate your soup from satisfactory to exceptional. The broth is the base of your soup and plays a key role in its flavor. You can make it using boxed chicken broth or by boiling a whole chicken with some simple seasonings.

When it comes to wine, it’s all about enhancing the flavor. Wine makes chicken mushroom soup taste better by releasing flavor molecules in the ingredients and bringing out their unique flavors. It also complements the flavors of mushrooms, making them more pronounced.

So, what wines go best with chicken mushroom soup? You can go for red wines like tannic reds, or white wines like Chardonnay. Pairing the right wine with your soup can really elevate your dining experience and make your chicken mushroom soup even more enjoyable.


So there you have it - the ultimate guide to the perfect chicken mushroom soup. We’ve covered everything from the basics to the unique twists you can add. From selecting the right chicken and mushrooms, crafting the perfect creamy base, mastering the cooking techniques, to exploring unique add-ins and toppings.

Remember, the beauty of cooking is in experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try new things and tweak the recipe to suit your taste. So, go ahead, grab your ingredients, and let’s make some soup!

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of chicken is best for chicken mushroom soup?

You can use either chicken breasts or thighs for your chicken mushroom soup. Chicken breasts cook faster and are lean, while thighs offer a richer flavor. Choose based on your preference.

What kind of mushrooms should I use for chicken mushroom soup?

You can use a variety of mushrooms like white or brown mushrooms, crimini, baby portobellos, or sliced portobellos in your chicken mushroom soup to add different layers of flavor.

How can I make my soup creamy without using heavy cream?

Try using alternative thickeners like flour or cornstarch, or go for a creamy base with coconut milk if you're avoiding dairy. Give it a shot, it might surprise you!

How can I store my leftover chicken mushroom soup?

You can store your leftover chicken mushroom soup in the refrigerator for 3-4 days in an airtight container, or freeze it for up to four months for longer storage. Enjoy your soup!

Can I add other meats to my chicken mushroom soup?

Yes, feel free to add other meats like beef or seafood to your chicken mushroom soup for added flavor and protein. Enjoy experimenting with different combinations!

previous post Older Post
next postNewer Post

Best Sellers

Tasty & wholesome 90-second meals. Free shipping & money-back guarantee!

post that might interest you

Close (esc)

Join the Soup Revolution

We're changing the way soup is enjoyed and pre-orders are open now! Order now to be part of our first delicious batch!

Pre-order Now

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


my cart

oh no!
your cart is empty
but it doesn’t have to be...
Shop now