New here? Get 100% back on your first meal in store

Halloween Pumpkin Stuffed Peppers: A Festive Dinner with Chicken Alfredo Pasta

By Proper Good2 min read

Jump to recipe
Pumpkin peppers stuffed with Proper Good Chicken Alfredo Pasta

Looking for a creative, savory dish to serve this Halloween? These Pumpkin Stuffed Peppers are the perfect mix of festive and flavorful! Made with orange bell peppers carved into jack-o’-lantern faces and filled with creamy Proper Good Chicken Alfredo Pasta, this dish is a guaranteed crowd-pleaser. Not only is it fun to make, but the quick prep time also makes it a great option for busy Halloween evenings.


Ingredients You’ll Need

4 items
  • Orange bell peppers (one per serving)
  • Proper Good Chicken Alfredo Pasta
  • Half a cup of water
  • Your favorite cheese (optional for topping)

How to Make Halloween Pumpkin Stuffed Peppers

1. Heat the Oven

  1. Step 1: Heat the oven to 400 degrees. 

2. Carve the Peppers

  1. Step 2: Cut the tops off the orange bell peppers and remove the seeds and membranes inside. Use a small knife to carve fun or spooky jack-o’-lantern faces on the front of each pepper—get creative with scary, silly, or traditional pumpkin designs!

3. Stuff the Peppers

  1. Step 3: We used creamy Proper Good Chicken Alfredo Pasta to stuff our peppers and it was Fantastic! After you stuff them, add a heaping pile of your favorite cheese. Although this step is optional, we highly recommend!!

4. Bake

  1. Step 4: Poor 1 1/2 cups of water to the bottom of your baking pan. Place them in the oven uncovered. It only takes 10-15 minutes but you can leave it in longer if you prefer crispier cheese!

  2. Step 5: Note: The water added to the baking pan helps the peppers soften from the steam. 

  3. Step 6: Get ready to impress your guests or family with this spooky and scrumptious meal. Halloween Pumpkin Stuffed Peppers with Proper Good Chicken Alfredo Pasta are sure to become a new Halloween favorite!